« 中華民國新聞記者信條 | 回到主頁面 | 降旗之後 »
2006-11-22, 10:39 PM
見微知著：談邵曉鈴車禍事件
胡志強、邵曉鈴的車禍事件這幾天被媒體炒得沸沸湯湯，在這事件中我們到底可以以什麼樣的觀點來作觀察呢？我先試著就一些話題來延伸討論，並且提出一些觀點，希望能引出更深刻的討論。但是我希望是透過這事件導向對於現象的觀察、討論，而不是再次的消費這事件。
蘋果日報不適當的頭版照片
首先，Pala站長有這麼一篇文章：我們不要血腥蘋果，點出了蘋果日報長久以來的問題。這個問題可以遠一點從「英國質報、小報與狗仔隊」的角度，或是「香港八卦媒體的操作方式」的觀點來觀察。但是這種現象並不是僅止於蘋果日報，眾新聞媒體亦是操作著這種屍體、肉體、血液、眼淚等...以作為新聞價值。
在HEMiDEMi上的討論中，提到：新聞局長鄭文燦責成主管蘋果日報的台北市新聞處對蘋果日報開罰，但卻無法可管。最後僅提出書面譴責，並將資料交付台北市社會局依兒童福利法開罰，但是再缺乏具體事證的狀況下，也似乎無法依法開罰。
但是就言論自由、新聞自由的觀點來看，我個人是認為儘管蘋果日報濫用自由，但是台灣的言論自由是多少人流血流汗、付出生命而取得的，絕對不可因為這樣的現象而放棄自由。這是一個新聞倫理的問題（參照：中華民國新聞記者信條），也是一個媒體社會責任的問題。如果今天媒體不願自律、放棄社會責任。我認為是應該由社會大眾、專業人士共同提出譴責。就算是不斷的對牛彈琴，我想也會有頑石點頭的可能。
至於蘋果日報使用圖像的問題，我是想從視覺傳播的角度來作分析。這與新聞台使用SNG即時轉播的問題是一樣的：到底圖像是否能代表真實？
圖像的真實面
繼續上面的問題：圖像是否能代表真實？不管是即時的事件現場照片，或者是透過SNG的影像呈現，我們必須思考的是這些影像是否真的表達出了真實？就算是呈現了部份的真實，又是否能代表事件全部的真實？這是一個對於攝影批判性的思考，先不在此深入討論，有興趣的可以閱讀郭力昕老師的《書寫攝影》一書。
但是這些影像使用在媒體上即是一種專業上的退守，一方面放棄了身為守門人的責任，另外一方面使用這些「見似真實」的影像，遮斷了「被呈現的真實」與「事件本身的真實」間的種種思考，等於是對閱聽人的欺瞞與鄙視（認為閱聽人需要這些血淋淋的影像、認為閱聽人缺乏對圖像思考的能力）。此外，使用SNG的現場畫面去充填新聞時段、或是粗糙未經篩選使用圖像，更是放棄己身的專業位置，可以說是偷懶不加思考的表現新聞。
在HEMiDEMi上的討論中還有提及對於戰爭影像、普立茲獎等等的討論，也可以參考這一篇：蘋果日報兩張死人照片得獎。這一篇的討論中有提及Robert Capa：這一位20世紀最具盛名的戰地記者，他的名言是：「如果你的照片不夠好，那就是你站得不夠近。」
是的，我們對於新聞照片仍然是用這種觀點來評斷其價值。我認為，如果我們否定蘋果日報那樣子呈現，就不該肯定這些戰場上的影像以所謂「人道」、「呈現戰爭的殘酷」的方式呈現戰爭這個更大的惡。右邊這張圖片是他最著名的照片「士兵之死( Death of a loyalist soldier)」，也是最具影響力的一張照片。長久以來對其真偽亦有所懷疑，雖然最後被證明為真，但是我們也可以思考這樣的問題：假的照片是不是也透露出部份的真實，同時可以達到同樣的人道目的？
我不是認為假造、修飾過的照片可以作為新聞照片使用，畢竟這與新聞倫理衝突。但是也給予我們一個新的思考方向，是否可以使用其他的影像來達到同樣的目的？就以前面郭力昕老師書中的一個例子，英國《衛報》在呈現男同性戀導演Derek Jarman的過世時，使用了一張掘墓人正在挖墓穴的照片，是否我們的媒體也可以對於使用圖像這件事作更為深刻、創意、精緻的思考，而不是用那樣血肉糢糊的照片來呈現事件。原文如此提到：
一個中距離帶遠景的鏡頭，安靜空曠的墓園，一棵枯樹，掘墓人兀自鏟著土。這張照片蘊含了太多的意思在其中：他是一個賈曼生平的影像濃縮版本，一語道盡了他勇敢而孤獨地走在社會與藝術邊緣的生命情境...若抽離其象徵意義的的這張照片本身，並沒有那麼的不同凡響，而放在這個事件與背景之中，他真正是一幅勝過千言萬語的影像論與散文詩。這種處理新聞照片的境界與氣魄，台灣的報紙主編與報老闆，不知何年何月方能懂得借鏡。
（郭力昕《書寫攝影》P.121, 搖旗人與掘墓人, 1994/10/28）
過度的新聞亦盡了社會責任？
社會責任這方面，我想媒體可能會辯解：我們也因為這則新聞推動了立法啊？怎麼能說無視社會責任呢？談到傳媒的社會責任可以參照RichyLi的這一篇：我的畢業禮物。
相對的，這次的事件透露出媒體與我們的政府與立法機關的懶惰。如此多的大客車、砂石車肇事，超速、酒駕等事件，卻無法要求政府嚴格執法、立法，也無法要求汽車製造商注重安全、要求地方政府把路鋪好一點，一直到了這事件才集體性的赫然醒覺，請問：平日新聞中的死傷者僅是為了填上空白的新聞時段，而無法成為一種人道的壓力嗎？
況且這數天的新聞現象，不外乎一再消費邵曉鈴的的重傷、胡志強的眼淚，不停著侵犯各種空間中當事者的隱私。以迷信荒謬的方式分析著傷者的姓名、將胡市長夫婦過往的一切翻出來消費、只為了取得獨家，便如禿鷹一般生吞活剝這一切。媒體們牽著手往新聞的最低標準前進，要如何顯示你們的關懷？又如何盡你們的社會責任？
嗯...我們能作些什麼？不停的抗議、不停的表示不滿、寫封對媒體的抗議信、在Blog上貼上拒絕媒體的貼紙、少買一分報紙、少看一分鐘新聞。總是會有改變吧？
董福興 發表 | [新聞觀察] , [書寫攝影] | 單篇網址 | 迴響 (194) | 引用 (0)
引用
http://www.bigsound.org/mt-tb.cgi/1615
迴響
Good site. Thanks!!!
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 May 16, 2007 10:27 PM
Very good site. Thank you!!!
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 May 16, 2007 11:31 PM
My best sites
i am american
由 freepornoclipss 發表於 May 19, 2007 11:09 PM
My best sites
i am american
由 freepornoclipss 發表於 May 19, 2007 11:10 PM
Cool site. Thanks!
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 23, 2007 2:22 AM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 23, 2007 8:10 AM
Good site. Thank you!!!
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 23, 2007 1:26 PM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 23, 2007 2:51 PM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 23, 2007 2:51 PM
Good site. Thank you!!!
由 moving truck rental 發表於 May 23, 2007 8:49 PM
Good site. Thank you!!!
由 moving truck rental 發表於 May 23, 2007 8:50 PM
Cool site. Thanks!
由 moving truck rental 發表於 May 23, 2007 10:49 PM
Very good site. Thank you:-)
由 moving truck rental 發表於 May 24, 2007 1:46 AM
Very good site. Thank you:-)
由 moving truck rental 發表於 May 24, 2007 1:46 AM
Very good site. Thanks:-)
由 budget truck rental 發表於 May 24, 2007 9:09 AM
Very good site. Thanks:-)
由 budget truck rental 發表於 May 24, 2007 3:44 PM
Good site. Thanks!
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 24, 2007 6:42 PM
Good site. Thanks!
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 24, 2007 6:43 PM
Cool site. Thanks:-)
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 24, 2007 10:36 PM
Very good site. Thank you:-)
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 25, 2007 1:20 AM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 25, 2007 5:14 AM
Good site. Thank you!!!
由 buy tramadol 發表於 May 25, 2007 12:04 PM
Good site. Thank you!
由 software 發表於 May 31, 2007 9:55 AM
Nice site. Thank you!
由 software 發表於 May 31, 2007 10:20 PM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 tramadol online 發表於 June 4, 2007 6:56 AM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 tramadol online 發表於 June 4, 2007 6:56 AM
Nice site. Thanks:-)
由 composer ringtones 發表於 June 5, 2007 11:32 AM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 viagra side effects 發表於 June 6, 2007 3:14 AM
Nice site. Thank you!
由 effects of ultram 發表於 June 6, 2007 3:51 AM
Very good site. Thanks.
由 meridia order 發表於 June 10, 2007 2:28 AM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 buy c d o valium 發表於 June 11, 2007 7:29 AM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 renters insurance 發表於 June 11, 2007 9:39 PM
Good site. Thanks.
由 florida department of insurance 發表於 June 12, 2007 7:27 AM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 boat insurance 發表於 June 12, 2007 7:36 PM
Very good site. Thank you!!!
由 instant payday loans 發表於 June 14, 2007 5:02 AM
Very good site. Thanks:-)
由 truck rental leasing 發表於 June 15, 2007 7:36 AM
Very good site. Thank you!!!
由 hertz truck rental 發表於 June 15, 2007 9:22 PM
Good site. Thank you!
由 hertz discount car rental 發表於 June 16, 2007 1:12 AM
Cool site. Thanks!!!
由 discount airport car rental 發表於 June 16, 2007 3:41 AM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 vicodin and pregnancy 發表於 June 16, 2007 9:22 AM
Good site. Thanks!
由 last minute car rental 發表於 June 16, 2007 11:24 AM
Cool site. Thank you.
由 discount car rental rates 發表於 June 16, 2007 11:36 PM
Good site. Thank you!!!
由 low cost car rental 發表於 June 17, 2007 1:05 AM
Nice site. Thanks.
由 discount orlando car rental 發表於 June 17, 2007 6:01 AM
Nice site. Thanks!
由 marilyn manson ringtone 發表於 June 17, 2007 6:44 AM
Nice site. Thanks.
由 discount car rental companies 發表於 June 17, 2007 7:48 AM
Good site. Thanks:-)
由 discount car rental los angeles 發表於 June 17, 2007 10:26 AM
Very good site. Thank you!
由 miami discount car rental 發表於 June 17, 2007 11:31 AM
Nice site. Thank you!
由 last minute deals on car rentals 發表於 June 18, 2007 8:39 AM
Very good site. Thanks!
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 June 19, 2007 5:02 PM
Very good site. Thank you:-)
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 June 19, 2007 6:48 PM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 Lindsay Lohan photo 發表於 June 19, 2007 7:12 PM
Good site. Thank you!
由 automotive de insurance wilmington 發表於 June 20, 2007 2:20 AM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 norco online 發表於 June 20, 2007 6:29 AM
Very good site. Thanks!
由 car elephant insurance quote 發表於 June 20, 2007 2:09 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 car elephant insurance quote 發表於 June 21, 2007 5:06 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 car elephant insurance quote 發表於 June 21, 2007 5:07 PM
Good site. Thanks!
由 automotive de insurance wilmington 發表於 June 21, 2007 7:04 PM
Cool site. Thank you!
由 car elephant insurance quote 發表於 June 22, 2007 12:06 AM
Cool site. Thank you!
由 car elephant insurance quote 發表於 June 22, 2007 12:07 AM
Good site. Thank you!
由 tamil ringtones 發表於 June 22, 2007 2:48 AM
FedEx overnight shipping, free prescription with your order and 24/7 customer service, http://BuyTramadolOnline.ws
由 Tramadol tablet 發表於 June 22, 2007 10:48 AM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 adipex pill 發表於 June 23, 2007 5:15 PM
Very good site. Thanks!!!
由 personal creations 發表於 June 24, 2007 11:22 AM
Very good site. Thank you:-)
由 store credit cards 發表於 June 26, 2007 4:08 PM
Good site. Thanks.
由 universal life insurance 發表於 June 26, 2007 8:02 PM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 diazepam no prescription 發表於 June 27, 2007 2:04 PM
Nice site. Thanks.
由 tramadol withdrawal symptom 發表於 June 28, 2007 1:19 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 ultraviolet 發表於 June 28, 2007 1:57 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 ultraviolet 發表於 June 28, 2007 1:58 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 tramadol 377 發表於 June 28, 2007 2:52 PM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 tramadol dream pharmaceutical 發表於 June 28, 2007 8:28 PM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 tramadol dream pharmaceutical 發表於 June 28, 2007 8:28 PM
Nice site. Thanks:-)
由 fall creek 發表於 June 29, 2007 2:09 AM
Nice site. Thanks:-)
由 fall creek 發表於 June 29, 2007 2:09 AM
Good site. Thanks!
由 tramadol on line 發表於 June 29, 2007 2:43 AM
Good site. Thanks!
由 tramadol on line 發表於 June 29, 2007 2:44 AM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 tramadol hydrochloride tablets 發表於 June 29, 2007 7:51 AM
Good site. Thanks!!!
由 tramodol 發表於 June 29, 2007 9:36 AM
Good site. Thanks:-)
由 disposable antiskid shoe covers 發表於 June 29, 2007 7:13 PM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 desk prescription tramadol 發表於 June 30, 2007 2:09 AM
Very good site. Thank you:-)
由 tramadol hci tablets 發表於 June 30, 2007 5:49 AM
shloculdogwa! big natural tit fuck amateur big interracial tit big boob tit ass free daily big tit video clip free big tit porn video free big tit teen pic big free nude tit video big pantie picture tit trading wife big skinny tit woman chubby woman with big tit young teen big tit hentai lesbian big tit big tit pic gallery posts big old saggy tit black woman with big tit big movie natural tit nice big tit big black nude tit amateur big fuck tit big hardcore site tit video ass big gallery round tit fuck video big tit free vintage big tit gallery big tit mature xxx free big tit mpeg big black african tit big tit fuck vids free big tit hentai big natural asian tit big fuck mature tit big free pic teen tit big white tit and ass big black blonde tit blonde big tit blow job big tit boob big black breast dick tit big black nipples tit big cute mature tit teen with big tit getting fucked big tit anime big tit cum shot clip big clip mature movie tit woman big tit sex movie big has tit wife big free mature tit big mature sperm swallow tit bbw big tit gallery big fuck tit young anal big hardcore tit big download movie sample tit big blonde fingering tit asian big naked tit babe big fuck hot tit big tit round ass debbie big clip free porn tit video big tit blonde fucking big gallery milf movie tit big tit big facial amateur big tit cum big big tit woman big tit porn star gallery free xxx big tit movie free big tit porn trailer hot ass big tit big free movie sexy tit big blonde facial tit big picture tit wife big gianna michaels tit work big tit fuck gallery big black naked tit woman milf mature big tit big cum milf tit big tit round ass pic big tit dot com blacks on blonde big tit ass big free porn tit big horny slut tit ass big natasha round tit big mature tit wife big free milf movie tit big tit nurse fuck big tit black porn star big tit free pic big fuck tit big tit patrol clip big pussy tight tit asian big fuck tit big tit patrol video the very big natural tit big tit fuck big patrol reynolds ryan tit big hardcore mature tit big tit woman big free fuck tit big blonde busty natural tit big tit ass picture big tit sample video big fat free hudge tit big porn tit work big black tit clip
由 ersfisme 發表於 July 1, 2007 3:27 AM
Nice site. Thanks!
由 honeycomb 發表於 July 1, 2007 8:14 AM
moxos gafijygu gokma
http://mwlukl.org/www-musicjesus-com.html vyjyg
由 lyziduhe 發表於 July 3, 2007 1:49 AM
Cool site. Thanks:-)
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 July 3, 2007 5:00 PM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 July 3, 2007 6:50 PM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 July 3, 2007 6:50 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 acs student loans 發表於 July 3, 2007 10:07 PM
Cool site. Thanks:-)
由 zocor side effects 發表於 July 4, 2007 9:56 AM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 haroace bixby 發表於 July 4, 2007 10:50 PM
Good site. Thank you:-)
由 case logic laptop backpack 發表於 July 5, 2007 2:06 PM
Good site. Thank you:-)
由 case logic laptop backpack 發表於 July 5, 2007 2:06 PM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 order ambien online 發表於 July 6, 2007 2:44 AM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 order ambien online 發表於 July 6, 2007 2:44 AM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 Medications and prescription drug information for consumers and medical health professionals. 發表於 July 6, 2007 3:40 AM
Good site. Thanks!!!
由 ringtone wav 發表於 July 6, 2007 9:21 PM
Good site. Thanks!!!
由 ringtone wav 發表於 July 6, 2007 9:22 PM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 greenpoint mortgage 發表於 July 9, 2007 5:23 AM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 greenpoint mortgage 發表於 July 9, 2007 5:23 AM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 hydrocodone drug 發表於 July 9, 2007 11:45 AM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 online prescription tramadol 發表於 July 11, 2007 7:42 AM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 online prescription tramadol 發表於 July 11, 2007 7:42 AM
Very good site. Thanks!!!
由 cheap tramadol online 發表於 July 11, 2007 2:13 PM
Cool site. Thanks:-)
由 cheap tramadol buy online 發表於 July 11, 2007 4:14 PM
Nice site. Thanks!
由 online pharmacy tramadol 發表於 July 11, 2007 8:07 PM
Nice site. Thanks!
由 online pharmacy tramadol 發表於 July 11, 2007 8:07 PM
Good site. Thank you:-)
由 order tramadol online 發表於 July 11, 2007 9:28 PM
Very good site. Thanks:-)
由 tramadol for sale 發表於 July 11, 2007 11:40 PM
Very good site. Thanks:-)
由 tramadol for sale 發表於 July 11, 2007 11:40 PM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 car insurance quote 發表於 July 12, 2007 2:17 AM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 car insurance quote 發表於 July 12, 2007 2:17 AM
Very good site. Thank you!
由 tramadol drug test 發表於 July 12, 2007 2:58 AM
Very good site. Thanks.
由 the drug tramadol 發表於 July 12, 2007 5:41 AM
Nice site. Thank you!
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 July 12, 2007 10:36 AM
Nice site. Thanks!
由 honda accord 2008 發表於 July 12, 2007 11:55 AM
Good site. Thanks.
由 honda accord 2008 發表於 July 14, 2007 8:51 PM
Good site. Thank you!
由 unsecured debt consolidation loan 發表於 July 15, 2007 8:59 PM
Very good site. Thanks!!!
由 debt reduction credit card consolidation 發表於 July 16, 2007 1:27 AM
Nice site. Thanks:-)
由 consolidation loan debt reduction 發表於 July 16, 2007 10:06 AM
Nice site. Thanks:-)
由 consolidation loan debt reduction 發表於 July 16, 2007 10:06 AM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 zocor side effects 發表於 July 16, 2007 1:44 PM
Cool site. Thanks!!!
由 survey 0.42$ ultram 發表於 July 16, 2007 6:48 PM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 survey 042 ultram 發表於 July 16, 2007 8:51 PM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 ultram real estate agent name badge 發表於 July 17, 2007 12:48 AM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 2008 honda accord 發表於 July 17, 2007 5:08 AM
Nice site. Thanks!!!
由 top 20 business schools 發表於 July 17, 2007 10:35 AM
Very good site. Thank you!!!
由 used cars for sale in san antonio tx 發表於 July 27, 2007 4:46 AM
Very good site. Thank you!!!
由 used cars for sale in san antonio tx 發表於 July 27, 2007 4:46 AM
Good site. Thank you:-)
由 presario 700 software 發表於 July 28, 2007 1:31 AM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 pro skateboard setup wheels trucks berings etc 發表於 July 28, 2007 11:12 PM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 pro skateboard setup wheels trucks berings etc 發表於 July 28, 2007 11:12 PM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 tramadol free shipping 發表於 July 30, 2007 11:52 PM
Very good site. Thanks!
由 Order tramadol online 發表於 August 1, 2007 8:27 PM
Very good site. Thanks!
由 Order tramadol online 發表於 August 1, 2007 8:27 PM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 buy tramadol online cod 發表於 August 1, 2007 11:36 PM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 buy tramadol online cod 發表於 August 1, 2007 11:37 PM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 cheapest tramadol online 發表於 August 2, 2007 9:41 AM
Good site. Thanks.
由 cheap online order tramadol 發表於 August 2, 2007 11:26 AM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 online pharmacy tramadol 發表於 August 2, 2007 1:20 PM
Cool site. Thanks.
由 cod online tramadol 發表於 August 2, 2007 5:56 PM
Very nice point of view! Respect!
由 xeo777mosl 發表於 August 4, 2007 5:02 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 candy dishes 發表於 August 5, 2007 12:50 AM
Very nice point of view! Respect!
由 iho777moof 發表於 August 5, 2007 10:55 AM
Very nice point of view! Respect!
由 nro777molu 發表於 August 5, 2007 11:02 AM
Very good site. Thanks!!!
由 ringtone 發表於 August 5, 2007 6:18 PM
Very good site. Thanks:-)
由 mob ringtones 發表於 August 5, 2007 9:53 PM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 union plus credit card 發表於 August 6, 2007 7:15 AM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 union plus credit card 發表於 August 6, 2007 7:16 AM
Very nice point of view! Respect!
由 oto777mobk 發表於 August 6, 2007 4:52 PM
Nice site. Thanks!
由 Adult dvd rental free trial 發表於 August 7, 2007 2:46 AM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 Online dvd rental 發表於 August 7, 2007 6:09 AM
Nice site. Thanks.
由 Xxx dvd rental 發表於 August 7, 2007 8:20 AM
Cool site. Thanks:-)
由 Online adult dvd rental 發表於 August 7, 2007 11:05 AM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 Blockbuster dvd rental 發表於 August 7, 2007 12:36 PM
Nice site. Thank you:-)
由 Movie dvd video rental 發表於 August 7, 2007 2:17 PM
Good site. Thanks:-)
由 Video and dvd rental or sales 發表於 August 7, 2007 4:05 PM
Good site. Thanks:-)
由 Video and dvd rental or sales 發表於 August 7, 2007 4:05 PM
Good site. Thank you!!!
由 Aarp health insurance 發表於 August 7, 2007 6:58 PM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 aarp reverse mortgage 發表於 August 7, 2007 8:31 PM
Cool site. Thank you:-)
由 aarp reverse mortgage 發表於 August 7, 2007 8:32 PM
Cool site. Thank you.
由 title loans 發表於 August 7, 2007 8:49 PM
Cool site. Thank you.
由 title loans 發表於 August 7, 2007 8:50 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 mortgage lender 發表於 August 7, 2007 8:54 PM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 mortgage lender 發表於 August 7, 2007 8:55 PM
Good site. Thank you!
由 aarp term life insurance 發表於 August 7, 2007 10:15 PM
Cool site. Thank you!
由 aarp life insurance 發表於 August 8, 2007 1:45 AM
Cool site. Thank you!
由 aarp life insurance 發表於 August 8, 2007 1:46 AM
Good site. Thank you!!!
由 aarp mobile home insurance 發表於 August 8, 2007 3:22 AM
Very nice point of view! Respect!
由 jgo777mohw 發表於 August 8, 2007 4:23 AM
Nice site. Thank you!!!
由 aarp car insurance 發表於 August 8, 2007 4:52 AM
Nice site. Thank you!
由 medicine ultram 發表於 August 8, 2007 8:11 AM
Nice site. Thank you!
由 medicine ultram 發表於 August 8, 2007 8:12 AM
Good site. Thank you.
由 refinance second mortgage 發表於 August 8, 2007 9:12 AM
Good site. Thanks!!!
由 refinance home mortgage rate 發表於 August 8, 2007 10:47 AM
Good site. Thanks!!!
由 refinance home mortgage rate 發表於 August 8, 2007 10:47 AM
Nice site. Thank you!
由 arizona refinance mortgage rate 發表於 August 8, 2007 12:15 PM
Good site. Thanks.
由 mortgage loan refinance and debt consolidation 發表於 August 8, 2007 1:55 PM
Cool site. Thanks!
由 no cost mortgage refinance 發表於 August 8, 2007 7:01 PM
Cool site. Thanks!
由 no cost mortgage refinance 發表於 August 8, 2007 7:03 PM
Good site. Thank you!
由 mortgage refinance california 發表於 August 8, 2007 8:29 PM
Nice site. Thanks:-)
由 mortgage calculator refinance breakeven 發表於 August 8, 2007 9:54 PM
Nice site. Thanks:-)
由 mortgage calculator refinance breakeven 發表於 August 8, 2007 9:54 PM
Very nice point of view! Respect!
由 koo777mozv 發表於 August 8, 2007 10:11 PM
good site! pesdato
由 gyo777mouc 發表於 August 8, 2007 10:12 PM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 hydrocodone dosage 發表於 August 8, 2007 10:37 PM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 hydrocodone dosage 發表於 August 8, 2007 10:37 PM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 coop manhattan mortgage rate refinance 發表於 August 8, 2007 11:32 PM
Nice site. Thank you.
由 coop manhattan mortgage rate refinance 發表於 August 8, 2007 11:33 PM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 refinance mortgage interest rate 發表於 August 9, 2007 1:00 AM
Cool site. Thank you!!!
由 refinance mortgage interest rate 發表於 August 9, 2007 1:00 AM
Nice site. Thanks.
由 dental insurance 發表於 August 9, 2007 5:40 AM
I like it! 458fc1d0d6ac7db926bc5d150a23a3d9
由 jflokomotivewq 發表於 August 9, 2007 9:08 PM
I like it! 2b440fe4338eefb677f685ea65f1c591
由 tklokomotiveth 發表於 August 9, 2007 9:16 PM
